Nux Vomica | Materia Medica by E. B. Nash
Eugene Beauharnais “E. B.” Nash (8 March 1838 – 6 November 1917) was one of America’s leading 19th-century homeopaths.
Born in Hillsdale, New York, Nash graduated from Cleveland Homoeopathic Medical College in 1874. He served as Professor of Materia Medica in the New York Homeopathic Medical College, and also taught at the Homoeopathic Hospital of London.
List of all Homeopathic Materia Medica: Dr.Clarke, Boericke, Farrington, Allen, Dunham, N M Choudhury, Nash, Boger, Lippe, Mure, Tyler, Constantine Hering, Kent, Homeopathic Materia Medica, Online Materia Medica
For very particular, careful, zealous persons, inclined to get excited or angry, spiteful, malicious disposition, mental workers or those having sedentary occupations.
Over-sensitiveness, easily offended; very little noise frightens, cannot bear the least even suitable medicine; faints easily from odors, etc.
Twitchings, spasms, convulsion, < slightest touch.
Chilliness, even during high fever; least uncovering brings on chilliness. Very red face.
Persons addicted to stimulants, narcotics, patent medicines, nostrums, debauchees, etc.
Frequent and ineffectual desire for stool or passes little at a time, > after stool.
Modalities: < uncovering, mental work, after eating, cold air, dry weather, stimulants, 9 A. M. ; > wet weather, warm room, on covering, after stool.
SPASM (from simple twitchings to the clonic form); SENSITIVENESS, NERVOUS and CHILLINESS are three general characteristics of this remedy.
Anxiety with irritability and inclination to commit suicide, but is afraid to die.
Sleepy in the evening, hours before bedtime; lies awake for an hour or two, at 3 or 4 A. M., then wants to sleep late in morning.
Awakens tired and weak and generally worse, with many complaints.
Stomach: Pressure an HOUR or TWO after eating as from a stone (immediately after, KALI BI., NUX M.).
Convulsions with consciousness (STRYCH.); < anger, emotion, touch, moving, alternate constipation and diarrhoea (ANT. CRUD.).
Menses: Too early, profuse and lasting too long, with aggravation of all other complaints during their continuance.
NUX VOMICA acts best when given at night, during repose of mind and body; SULPH. in the morning.
Among the symptoms called characteristic, as given by Constantine Hering, are these:
“After aromatics in food or as medicine, particularly ginger, pepper, etc., and after almost any kind of so-called ‘hot’ medicines (Goullon).” Also, “will also benefit persons who have been drugged by mixtures, bitters, herbs and so-called vegetable pills, etc.—(B.)”
This is putting it in too wholesale a fashion. It would be true if said that NUX VOMICA will OFTEN benefit such cases. The fact is that it will benefit those cases in which the use of such drugs, aromatics, pills, etc., has brought about a condition that simulates the symptoms produced in the provings of NUX VOMICA, or in cases to which it is homeopathic, and no others. Another fact is that these things often DO produce such a condition, and that is one reason why so many physicians are almost invariably prescribing NUX VOMICA the first thing, in cases coming from allopathic hands, without even examining the case. But it is unscientific. We have a law of cure, and there are cases in which the NUX VOMICA condition is NOT present but another more similar remedy must be given. It does not alter the case to say, “Well, I did not know what had been given,” for NUX VOMICA will neither antidote the effects of the drug poison nor cure the disease condition unless it is homeopathically indicated, especially if given in the dynamic form.
Here are two more of Hering’s card symptoms, in which are given the temperaments that are most susceptible to the action of NUX:
“Over-sensitiveness, every harmless word offends, every little noise frightens, anxious and beside themselves, they cannot bear the least even suitable medicines.—(B.)” And, “For very particular, careful, zealous persons, inclined to get excited and angry, or of a spiteful, malicious disposition.”
This is a graphic picture of what is called the “Nervous temperament,” and practice corroborates the truth of the value of these temperamatic indications for this remedy; but there are a number of remedies that have as markedly this so-called nervous temperament, such as CHAMOMILLA, IGNATIA, STAPHYSAGRIA, and others.
So no physician would be justified in prescribing NUX VOMICA on temperament alone, be the indication ever so clear. The WHOLE CASE must come in. There seems to be another kind of condition belonging to this nervous group of NUX VOMICA that has not so much of the excitable in it. “Hypochondriasis, with studious men, sitting too much at home, with abdominal complaints and costiveness.”
Now, if you take a second look at these cases, you will find that a very little irritation will arouse this kind out of their hypochondriac gloom and make them angry or irritable similar to the first condition, so that on the whole the first proves to be the predominant one.
If the gloomy or hypochondriac condition of mind persists, we will more likely have to look to such remedies as AURUM, NAT. MUR., etc., to find the true simillimum. These nervous symptoms of mind and body are wonderful leaders to the selection of the right remedy.
“FREQUENT AND INEFFECTUAL DESIRE TO DEFAECATE OR PASSING BUT SMALL QUANTITIES OF FACES AT EACH ATTEMPT.“
This symptom is pure gold. There are a few other remedies that have it, but none so positively and persistently.
It is the guiding symptom in the constipation to which NUX VOMICA is homeopathic, and in my experience will then, and then only, cure.
Carrol Dunham wrote over twenty-five years ago on this symptom. He said, in effect—while NUX VOMICA or BRYONIA are equal remedies for constipation there was never any reason for confounding them, or alternating them, as they were so different. The NUX VOMICA constipation was caused by irregular peristaltic action of the intestines, hence the frequent ineffectual desire; but the BRYONIA constipation was caused by lack of secretion in the intestines. There was with BRYONIA absolutely no desire, and the stools were dry and hard as if burnt.
And the above symptom is found not in constipation alone. It is always present in dysentery. The stools, though very frequently consisting of slimy mucus and blood, are small and very unsatisfactory. Dr. P. P. Wells pointed out the very reliable additional symptom for NUX VOMICA in dysentery—that the PAINS WERE VERY GREATLY RELIEVED FOR A SHORT TIME AFTER EVERY STOOL. This is not so with MERCURY, but the pain and tenesmus continue AFTER the stool, as it is sometimes well expressed as “a never-get-done” feeling. But it makes little difference whether the patient is afflicted with constipation, dysentery, diarrhoea or other diseases, if we have this frequent ineffectual desire for stool present we always think of NUX VOMICA first, and give it unless other symptoms contra-indicate it.
“CATAMENIA A FEW DAYS BEFORE TIME, AND RATHER TOO COPIOUS, OR KEEPING ON SEVERAL DAYS LONGER WITH COMPLAINTS AT THE ONSET, WHICH REMAIN UNTIL AFTER IT IS OVER.“
This is also an oft-verified symptom of NUX VOMICA. Of course there are many other remedies for too early or too copious menstruation. CALCAREA OSTREARUM is one of them, but the temperament of the CALCAREA patient is not at all like NUX VOMICA. I have found that patients that required NUX VOMICA for this condition could hardly ever take PULSATILLA for anything. For instance, if the patients had a green, bland, thick discharge and you gave them PULSATILLA it would often bring on too early and profuse menstruation. In such cases I had to give SEPIA, which would act like a charm on the catarrh and not aggravate the menses.
These cases calling for NUX VOMICA often occur in young girls or women at the climacteric. We often have the characteristic rectal troubles also present. (LILIUM TIG.) The pains are pressing down and extend to the rectum and sometimes also to the neck of the bladder. Inefficient LABOR PAINS, extending to rectum, with desire for stool or frequent urination, are quickly relieved, and become efficient, after the administration of a dose of NUX VOMICA 200.
If, in addition, your menorrhagic patient is costive, has gastric troubles, and especially if generally < in the morning, we have an almost sure remedy in NUX VOMICA.
“FEELS WORSE IN THE MORNING SOON AFTER AWAKING (LACH. and NAT. MUR.), ALSO AFTER MENTAL EXERTION (NAT. CARB., vertigo; CALC. OST., SILICEA, occipital); AFTER EATING (ANACARD., reverse), AND IN COLD AIR (PULS., reverse).” If Boenninghausen had never done anything but give us his incomparable chapter on aggravations and ameliorations, this alone would have immortalized him.
It seems to me, after profiting by them in a practice of over thirty years, it is impossible to over-estimate them.
But some one will say, perhaps—there are twenty-eight remedies in Allen’s BOENNINGHAUSEN, in large caps, that are worse in the morning. That does not seem like coming very close to a choice of the single remedy.
But, when we look at those that are worse in the evening, we find thirty-eight remedies, and only eight of them occurring under BOTH morning and evening, and these eight are worse not GENERALLY, but rather in some ESPECIAL symptoms. For instance, in RHUS the loose cough is worse in the morning, the tight, dry one in the evening.
So you see we are quite on the way to making a choice after all. But now take all the aggravations of NUX VOMICA as regards time, mind, gastric (symptoms), temperature, etc., where can you find the combination so prominently under any other remedy? Of course those physicians who are not able to appreciate anything but pathological symptoms have not much use for these modalities. But one thing is certain, they cannot do as good homeopathic work without as with them.
“GREAT HEAT, WHOLE BODY BURNING HOT, ESPECIALLY FACE RED AND HOT, YET THE PATIENT CANNOT MOVE OR UNCOVER IN THE LEAST WITHOUT FEELING CHILLY.” This condition of feverishness is of common occurrence and yields to NUX VOMICA with a promptness that would delight the heart of a Lippe. It makes no difference what the name of the fever, whether inflammatory, remittent, or fever accompanying sore throat, rheumatism, or any other local trouble, if we have these indications, we may confidently give this remedy and will not often be disappointed in the result. It took me years to learn the value of this symptom, because I was a routinist and thought that ACONITE, BELLADONNA, or both in alternation, must be given in all cases where high fever was present. So I have some sympathy for young physicians now, who from false teachings have been led into the same error. But let me say here, for the benefit of all such, that there is a much better way: namely—to closely individualize, which is not always difficult; give the single remedy in the potentized form, giving it time to act, and wait for reaction before repeating.
Of course low potencies will often cure, and that in spite of alternation, over-dosing, and frequent repetition. But they will often fail, and, in the great majority of cases, will not accomplish anything like the satisfactory results of the true simillimum, the single remedy, and the minimum dose.
“AFTER EATING: (KALI BICH., NUX MOSCHATA) SOUR TASTE, PRESSURE IN THE STOMACH AN HOUR OR TWO AFTERWARD, WITH HYPOCHONDRIACAL MOOD, PYROSIS, TIGHTNESS ABOUT WAIST; MUST LOOSEN CLOTHING (LACHESIS, CALCAREA AND LYCOPODIUM), CONFUSED, CANNOT USE MIND TWO OR THREE HOURS AFTER A MEAL, EPIGASTRIUM BLOATED, WITH PRESSURE AS FROM A STONE IN THE STOMACH.“
This is a group of symptoms as given in “Guiding Symptoms.” There are so many symptoms given under the digestive organs that it shows that NUX VOMICA has really a very wide range of action in gastric troubles. And there are no really characteristic and peculiar symptoms to mention, unless it be the peculiar aggravation of stomach symptoms “AN HOUR OR TWO AFTER EATING,” instead of immediately after, as is the case with NUX MOSCHATA and KALI BICHROMICUM. The pressure as from a stone occurs also under BRYONIA and PULSATILLA.
More stress may be placed upon the cause of the stomach, liver, and abdominal complaints for which NUX VOMICA is the remedy. For instance, coffee, alcoholic drinks, debauchery, abuse of drugs, business anxiety, sedentary habits, broken rest from long night watching (COCC, CUP. MET., NIT. AC), too high living, etc. So we find that NUX VOMICA is adapted to complaints arising from these causes, which is abundantly verified in practice.
One thing is very apt to be present in these cases: namely—the very characteristic rectal symptoms already noticed.
We ought not to leave NUX VOMICA without speaking of its great efficiency in headaches and backaches.
The headaches often occur in conjunction with the gastric, hepatic, abdominal and haemorrhoidal affections. Here also the modalities, more than the character of the pain, decide the choice. The aggravations are: from mental exertion, chagrin or anger; in open air (opposite PULSATILLA), on awaking in the morning, after eating, from abuse of coffee or spirits, sour stomach, in the sunshine, on stooping, from light and noise, when moving or opening the eyes (BRYONIA), from coughing, high living or highly seasoned food, in stormy weather, after drugging, from masturbation, from constipation or haemorrhoids.
These headaches may or may not localize in any particular part of the head.
The patient is just as apt to say in one part of the head as another, and will often say, in no particular part, “it feels badly and aches all over.”
The pains in the back are more peculiar. The patient is apt to have the backache in bed, and must sit up to turn over; as turning or twisting the body, aggravates when standing (SULPHUR) (worse when sitting, KOBALT, PULSATILLA, RHUS TOXICOD., ZINCUM), or sitting is especially painful. The pain is mostly located in the lumbar region, though it may be in the dorsa, and is often in connection (like AECULUS HIPP.) with haemorrhoids. AESCULUS is especially < from walking or stooping. Backache, caused by masturbation (KOBALT, < sitting; STAPHYSAGRIA, lying at night) finds one of its best remedies in NUX VOMICA. We might here launch out into a description of the general action of NUX VOMICA upon the spinal cord, including the motor and sensory centers, etc., but that can all be found in other works. So now we will leave NUX, except as we refer to it in comparison while writing of other remedies. In reviewing what we have written, we are impressed that some may be led to think that we have narrowed down the sphere of this truly great remedy too much. Let us say here, that it is not our aim in this work to write exhaustively upon any remedy, but to point out a few of the chief virtues and characteristic symptoms, around which all the rest revolve.
To write exhaustively would be to write a complete Materia Medica.
In actual practice there are two kinds of cases that come to every physician. One is the case that may be prescribed for with great certainty of success on the symptoms that are styled CHARACTERISTIC and PECULIAR. (Organon, § 153.) The other is where in all the case there are no such symptoms appearing; then there is only one way, viz., to hunt for the remedy that, in its pathogenesis, contains what is called the “TOUT ENSEMBLE” of the case. The majority of the cases, however, do have, standing out like beacon lights, some characteristic or keynote symptoms which guide to the study of the remedy that has the whole case in its pathogenesis.